askalanaquestion.com . . . a resource for pool and spa help and informed shopping!!!

 

Home page icom

  A backyard pool to enjoy all season long.   A backyard spa for pure enjoyment.   Shopping in the website stores.   ColorQ digital water analyzers, for pools and spas.   Big sale in the website store.   Pool and spa help-line.  
 

Welcome
Page

 

Pool
Problems
  Spa
Problems
  Website
Shopping
  Water
Testers
  What's
On Sale
  E-Mail A
Question
 


twitter.com/poolandspahelp

     


search tips sitemap

 

Chlorine Spa Sanitizers

Dealing with the many forms of this popular spa sanitizer.
 
The Pool and Spa Informational Website
askalanaquestion.com

A Popular Spa and Hot Tub Sanitizer Choice
 

 
 

Scroll down to browse through some archived SPA and Hot Tub questions and answers.  Please click the Spa Topics Link, on top of every page, to access a complete listing of Spa and Hot Tub Problem subjects, an alphabetized Website Table of Contents, Spa and Hot Tub Equipment Information, About Alan Biographic Material and a Spa and Hot Tub Glossary. Use the other links to access additional subject information. More information about some new and unique products, for Spas and Hot Tubs, can be found by visiting The Website Store. You'll never know what you'll find and that's always fun. Be better prepared and avoid costly problems!

 
Mini Salt Chlorine Generator, for spas and swim spas. Plug-n-Play Salt Chlorine Generators for spas. ChlorMaker IL inline spa saltwater system chlorine generator
Model SV battery-powered Spa Vacuum. One of the ColorQ all-digital, pool and spa water analyzers.
Nano-Stick Clarifiers, forall types of pools and spas. The Plug-n-Play Spa Salt Chlorine Generator, shown above, is available in 3 full-featured, affordable models.  Includes everything and absolutely no installation is required.  Just add a small amount of salt and plug in a GFI protected outlet.  This is definitely the better way to utilize chlorine. Nano-Spray uses new technology to help preserve spa covers.

Click any image for more product and ordering information.

Website Shipping is FREE* . . . within the Continental U.S.
* A $9.99 handling charge will apply to Continental U.S. Orders, under $74.99.  U.S. Orders outside of the Continental U.S. may require some additional charge, based on quantity and destination.

How to use chlorine, as a spa, swim spa or hot tub sanitizer? Chlorine is used as a spa or hot tub sanitizer, typically in the form of granular sodium dichlor. The other forms of chlorine, popular in pools, are not used in spas and hot tubs for a variety of seasons: solubility, build-up considerations and effect on the pH. Chlorine can used in another entirely different and better way: a salt chlorine generator uses ordinary salt and converts it into chlorine. This eliminates the need to handle, store or measure chlorine products.  Chlorine can used as a backup sanitizer or oxidizer, in conjunction with Ozonation, Mineral Sanitizers, UV Sanitizing or Ionization. If problems arise, refer to the Spa Problems Page, as a source of problem-solving information, broken down into various categories.  Scroll down the page and click on the linked keywords, catch phrases or images, in the archived answers below, to access additional information, on that topic or product.

Join our E-Letter Mailing List.
 

You'll receive 1-3 E-Letters a month, featuring helpful pool and spa advice, new product information and sale announcements.  All we require is your e-mail address and you can opt out anytime you wish.  Your information will never be shared or sold.
 

▼     Helpful, Problem-Solving Information, in a question and answer format.     ▼

Heavy Handed With Chlorine?

My husband and I just got a new hot tub. We are not very educated in balancing the chemicals. We were told to use Chlorinating Granules, and then later add Stabilizer/Conditioner after the chlorine level was satisfactory. Are these the only two products we will need to use? Are there products that are more highly recommended? Also, my husband misread the directions and added way too much chlorinating granules (about 5 Tablespoons instead of a teaspoon!). Is there a way to reestablish the balance in the water, or do we need to drain the hot tub and start all over? Thank you.

Derek and Laura, 5/6/2013


In addition to maintaining the sanitizer level, it is important to maintain the pH in the proper range. To help facilitate this, it is
Mini Salt Chlorine Generator, for spas and swim spas. important to maintain the total alkalinity as well. There may be other issues such as calcium hardness and heavy metals: usually a water analysis is used to determine any appropriate treatment. Unless your hot tub is left uncovered and in the Sun, there is no need to add chlorine stabilizer. The covering of the hot tub eliminates any such need. If your hot tub has been overdosed, there is a chemical (Chlorine Neutralizer) that can be added to quickly lower the chlorine level. A level of 1-3 PPM of Free Chlorine is recommended. Partial replacement of the water, especially in a freshly filled hot tub, is a wasteful means of control. Remember this! You can always add more - you can't take out!  Granular Chlorine is a hot tub and spa popular sanitizer. However, bromine can be used with a feeder or floater and has less odor. Salt Chlorine Generators, Ozone Generators, Mineral Sanitizers and Ultraviolet Sanitizers are other sanitizing possibilities. Browse through the archives for more on these topics. I hope that I have been helpful Enjoy the hot tub.

Sincerely. Alan Schuster, 5/6/2013


Too Much Stabilizer?

I just had my spa water tested. My cyanuric acid was over 300. The people I bought the spa from gave me chlorine granules. I notice now that they have stabilizer in them. Is this a common chemical to use in my spa? I drained the spa to get rid of the cyanuric acid. What is your opinion and what chlorine should I use and how much and how often. My water was getting cloudy when it was covered but would clear up when it was shocked and left open for the sun to hit. Please help me my wife and I are new to this spa thing. We have no problem with our pool.

Joe and Diana B., Jackson, NJ, 9/18/2012


Stabilizer serves no real purpose in a spa that is covered most of the time. The granular chlorine is a stabilized product and is the
mostPlug-n-Play Spa Salt Chlorine Generators. common type used in spas: not because it is stabilized, but because it is completely soluble and essentially pH neutral. High levels of cyanuric acid should be avoided because it can reduce chlorine effectiveness. If you are going to use chlorine, follow the directions on the package. Add enough product to maintain a Free Chlorine level of 1-3 PPM. Adding some after each use of the spa, will help decompose bather wastes. Shocking weekly will help maintain water quality and avoid the formation of resistant organisms. Shocking the pool cleared the water up, by re-establishing the chlorine level and destroying contamination. Exposure to the Sun was just coincidental. When chlorine stabilizer levels are above 150 PPM, it reduces chlorine's effectiveness, forcing you to maintain a higher level.  Spa water should be replaced every three months and that will lower the cyanuric acid level to zero.  There are other means of spa sanitizing that you might want to consider: bromine, salt chlorine generators, ozone generators, UV sanitizers and mineral sanitizers. I hope that I have been helpful.

Sincerely. Alan Schuster, 9/18/2012


The Chlorine Fairy?

Your website has provided a wealth of information for me being a new spa owner! Here is my question: We installed an ozonator in our 330 gallon spa (we bought it used in July,  its 4 years old) last week. We drained it, put fresh water in it and are using a mineral purifier as a backup sanitizer. I also immediately shocked it with dichlor and added baking soda to bring up the TA and pH. The chlorine level was high then went down, as expected to almost nothing. A few days after installing the ozonator, the water went cloudy and the pH was very high, over 8.4. So, I shocked it with NON-CHLORINE shock, added acid to bring the pH down and used water clarifier. The pH went down, the water cleared up but then my FREE CHLORINE level went up to 5 ppm and TOTAL CHLORINE went up to 10 ppm! Could non-chlorine shock bring the chlorine back up from almost nothing? Is the test strip incorrect? I also used an OTO test with the same result of TOTAL CHLORINE. I have NOT added any chlorine other than the initial shock at start-up. Since then the FREE CHLORINE has dropped to 1 ppm and TOTAL CHLORINE IS 5 ppm. How can I bring the chlorine level back down since I do not want ANY chlorine in my spa? I did add a small amount of fresh water but I don't think it has that much chlorine in it. Will I be able to have a chlorine-free spa or is there a chlorine fairy who comes during the night and adds it to my spa?

Aturina S., 9/13/2012


The combination of an ozonator and a mineral sanitizer can come close to meeting all of the needs of your spa. The addition of
One of the ColorQ all-digital, pool and spa water analyzers. the non-chlorine shock is intended to provide some further assurance that the oxidation needs are being met. If the ozonator is eliminating the bulk of the organic waste, there is little left for the non-chlorine shock to decompose and it will react with chlorides, present in the water, and will form chlorine. That is why your chlorine level rises, after this product is added. it has converted to chlorine. I suggest that you only add enough chlorine or non-chlorine shock to maintain a free chlorine level of 1 PPM. The presence of the ozonator and mineral sanitizer will reduce the amount of chlorine or shock that has to be added. Proper testing of free and total chlorine is important and OTO is an archaic method. I suggest using LaMotte Insta-Test strips or a ColorQ all-digital Water Analyzer, as they provide the right kind of information. I hope that this information will prove helpful.

Sincerely. Alan Schuster, 9/14/2012


Chlorine Won't Dissolve?

Hi Alan, I have an eight hundred gallon hot tub. Recently, I could not find any SPA chlorine, so I bought chlorine powder for a pool. It does not dissolve in my hot tub! WHY?

Alice, 1/16/2009


The only type of Granular Chlorine that is recommend for use in a spa is sodium dichlor. This product is completely soluble and is essentially pH neutral. These properties make it ideal for use as a spa chlorine. Other types are either too high in terms of the pH, are not completely soluble or are too slow to dissolve. You didn't supply the label information, so there is no way for me to be more specific. A guess would be that you bought calcium hypochlorite: a chlorine that is not completely soluble and is not recommended for spas. You might want to browse through the archives: there is information on other types of sanitizers that you might find more to your liking. If you want to stay with chlorine, a salt chlorine generator is the better way to do chlorine.  I hope that I have helped clear up the mystery.

Sincerely. Alan Schuster, 1/16/2009


Trouble Viewing The Colors?

I seem to have a problem determining the best match on a spa water tester. Is there an easier way?

Matt S., 8/02/2007


Lots of people have color matching problems and sometimes it is due to color blindness. The ColorQ PRO 7 Water Analyzer can easily solve your problem. It performs 7 different tests: pH, free and total chlorine, bromine, total alkalinity, cyanuric acid and calcium hardness. These are all of the common spa tests and the ColorQ is all digital. No colors to match and no charts to look up. Is very simple to used and is very affordable. It will build your confidence and keep you in control. You did not mention how the spa is being sanitizer. There are other ColorQ models and I am sure that one will be perfect for your needs. I hope that I have been helpful.

Sincerely. Alan Schuster, 8/3/2007


► Chlorine And Bromine?

Alan, tonight is (unfortunately) the first time I've looked at your website. Until today, I've relied on the hot tub sales-guy to answer my questions about chemicals. Here's where I'm at. I have a (600 gallon) hot tub. I've used dichlor as a sanitizer since I bought it last summer. I was leaving for a 9 day vacation a couple weeks ago so called the hot tub sales guy and asked him what to do about chemicals while I'm gone. He said to come in and get some bromine tablets and drop one in the little basket thing before leaving town. I said, "But I've heard that you can't just switch from bromine to chlorine and back again." He said, "Nah. You can switch back and forth without any problems. It's no big problem. Look at the ingredients in the bromine products. They're all 80% chlorine anyway. Don't worry about it." So I bought bromine tablets (from him), dropped one in the basket, and left town. When I came back (a couple days early because of sickness), I checked the tablet, saw that there was still a little bit in the basket, so I pulled it out. Then I did my normal non-chlorine shock and thought I was good to go with my normal dichlor routine. When I checked the tub for chlorine this afternoon, the strip came up white (when it should have some purple color in it). I added a couple cap-fulls of dichlor (an amount that would have normally -- before the bromine tablets - brought it up to an appropriate chlorine level [1-5 to 2 ppm), and called it good. I went out an hour or two later, used another test strip, and it came up white. I tossed in a couple more cap-fulls of dichlor, and tested it again. White. You see where I'm going. So I called the sales guy and asked him if maybe these test strips don't work in the cold (I'm in North Dakota; today's high was something like -3°F. He said they should work fine in the cold but that maybe I had gotten water in the container and that I should buy a new bottle of test strips. I did (from him). I came back home, tested it again, nothing. Added more dichlor. Tested again. You see where I'm going. At this point, I've probably thrown in 4 or 5 times more chlorine than it would normally require to bring from 0 to 1.5 or 2. Then I came inside and did what I should have done first; some online research. I see on your site and a couple others that you can't switch back and forth from chlorine to bromine and back. Based on my limited knowledge in the area, I am guessing what's happening is that all the chlorine I'm dumping in is converting to bromine. That's why the test-strips never show any chlorine. (Right?) So. Enough with the problem. Let's talk about solutions. Keeping in mind that the high temperatures here are supposed to be below zero for the next week or so, and I want to use the tub again, what should I do. Draining it would do little more than create a regulation sized hockey rink in my back yard. That seems unworkable. I am guessing the tub has a huge amount of bromine in it right now. What can I do to get the bromine levels under control and get the tub useable (or is it useable right now)? I'm assuming the best course of action is for me to just switch to bromine until spring (and maybe longer, if I've figured bromine out by then). What would you do? Any suggestions you have would be appreciated. Thanks.

Chad N., Bismarck, ND, 1/3/2009

P.S. Sorry I got so long winded.

You may be long winded, but you aren't close to the longest letter. You have some misinformation that needs to be addressed. Yes, if you have bromides present from bromine tablet use or from the addition of sodium bromide, chlorine will convert to
New!!!  One_Dip Insta_test Strips for pools and spas bromine. No, you can't have a large amount of bromine present, if all you added were a few bromine tablets. The amount of bromine is commensurate with the amount of bromides present: converted to bromine by chlorine or non-chlorine shock. You can convert from chlorine to bromine at will. To completely convert to chlorine, after having used the product for a while, you must replace the water. Here's what doesn't make sense. The test methods for chlorine and bromine are the same: only the color comparison charts are different. If you really had bromine present, it would register on the chlorine test. There are several possibilities: your chlorine level could actually be low, the test strips may be bad or the test strips do not work properly in the presence of high levels of chlorine or bromine. Inasmuch as I don't know the specific of your test strips, I can't speculate as to their suitability at high levels of chlorine or bromine. Test strips, such as Insta-Test Strips utilize a chemical called Syringaldazine, which is the best one to use in the presence of high levels of chlorine or bromine. You need to verify the test results with another product and/or test method. The limited use of the bromine tablets is not a part of this problem. It is far more likely that your spa has a high biological demand. Are the walls slimy? It could be possible that the problem was building over a few weeks, as a result of the sporadic and, possibly inadequate, addition of the dichlor. One way to avoid the ups and downs of sanitizer levels is to add an ozonator. This will allow you to reduce the amount of chemicals needed and help maintain proper sanitary conditions. I hope that I have been helpful.

Sincerely. Alan Schuster, 1/4/2009


Chlorine Is Not Necessarily The Best Choice?

Just tested out the ColorQ PRO 7, I have been fighting accuracy issues for some time now with test strips and trips to the local tub dealer. My most recent issue is with the delta being greater than 0.5 FCL just tested my 375 gallon hot tub at 102 degrees here are the results: FCL=2.88, TCL=7.32, pH=7.6, TA=108, CH=223, CYA=63. I'm not sure what to do to get the TCL down. I think that FCL is ok? Any suggestions? Thanks in advance.

Dennis D., Woodstock CT, 11/7/2008


Chlorine would not be my choice as a spa sanitizer, unless it was in the form of a salt chlorine generator. At
least, not as you are using it. The difference between the total and free chlorine readings is comChlorMaker IL inline spa saltwater system chlorine generatorbined chlorine: it can be odorous, irritating and ineffective as a sanitizer. To get the free chlorine and total chlorine reading closer, you will have to add about 40 PPM of free chlorine. Adding potassium monopersulfate is another solution, but I think there are better options. You could add a dose of sodium bromide solution (used in the bromine 2-part system) and continue with adding chlorine. The various forms of chlorine will convert the bromides into bromine. It will make the water smell better and simplify testing. You could also use bromine tablets in a feeder or floater.  To further assure proper water quality, you could add the SPA FROG mineral sanitizer. This will allow you to get suitable results, while maintaining lower chlorine or bromine readings. Adding an ozone generator would further improve water quality, while greatly reducing the chemical presence.  I hope that this information is helpful and thank your purchase of a ColorQ Water Analyzer. It definitely is a step up!

Sincerely. Alan Schuster, 11/8/2008


Where Does the Spa Chlorine Go?

Good day, Alan,  We are new to the world of spas here in Florida.  We use chlorine as our sanitizing agent. I don't understand why when you enter a spa and the chlorine and pH levels are where should be, and 30 min. later when you get out, the levels are much lower.  Is this normal? As I said, we are new in this arena.  I didn't realize that you had to add chemicals after, or before, each use.  Guess we can learn something new every day.

Joyce & Jim, Florida, 9/15/2007


The typical pool in your neighborhood has about 60 times more water than your spa. Add to this the fact that the spa is at a
much higher temperature and this will produce more bather wastes. This means that the typical spa gets more demands put on its sanitizing system than the typical; pool. Sanitizer levels can be depleted very quickly and it just makes sense to test the water and add more chlorine before and after each use. However, if the spa is equipped with an ozonator or UV sanitizing unit, less chlorine will be used. Ozone and UV units have controllable effects on the sanitation, while chlorine effectiveness rises and falls with its concentration. A salt chlorine generator is a very affordable way to maintain a spa's chlorine level and eliminates many other chlorine issues:  measuring, handling, storage and odor.  These alternative means of sanitizing spa water are more flexible and provide a higher degree of effectiveness through use of a backup system. I hope that I cleared up the mystery.

Sincerely. Alan Schuster, 9/15/2007


Favoring The Higher End?

Hello Allan. I'm on your site often and find it to be most informative. We maintain an 812 gallon, in ground, indoor spa, which uses chlorine for sanitation. The information left by the professional pool company indicates the chlorine should be maintained at 3 ppm minimum. I thought I noticed you suggested 1-3 ppm for a spa, which is what they suggested for the 18,000 gallon pool and 783 gallon kiddie pool. Does 3 ppm minimum seem high to you, or is this necessary for proper sanitation? What would be the safe, high-end of that range - 5 ppm? It gets very, very, very little use. Thank you kindly.
 
Tracy, 1/13/2009


Having one or two people in an 18,000 gallon spa has little short term effect on the chlorine level, given the volume of water. Putting the same two people in an 800 gallon has a much greater effect, given the smaller volume and higher temperatures.  For this reason, favoring the high end or slightly higher is preferred, so that sanitizer is present, when needed. A salt chlorine generator makes a for a better way to do chlorine, as it is controllable and eliminates the odorous forms, as well. I hope that this information is helpful.

Sincerely. Alan Schuster, 1/13/2009


Tablets In A Spa?

Sorry this might be wordy with a lot of different questions. I am currently using a natural product, with a granular chlorine. I should mention that I have The Magnetizer attached to the tub and have an ozonator that runs 24 hours a day. The granular chlorine I use is Sodium Dichloro-s-Triazinetrione 100%, with an available chlorine content of 62%. My question is, I find it hard to keep a Chlorine level of 1 -2 PPM with the granular dichlor and was looking at adding the Chlorine tablets that the dealer carries and wants me to use, which are composed of Trichloro-s-Triazinetrione 100%, with an available chlorine of 90%. Everywhere I look on your website you say not to use Trichlor in a spa. I am just trying to keep a minimal Chlorine reading to be safe, even though this natural product is said to kill bacteria. I have Bromine tablets at home and was wondering if I can use those in the floater and still use my Dichlor Chlorine with it when needed. My whole goal is to keep the Chlorine level as low as possible, when we are soaking because of skin sensitivities. I also would prefer Chlorine to Bromine and if I'm not confused, if I use Bromine tablets, any Chlorine I use will turn to Bromine! Is it safe to use the Chlorine tablets, if the floater will only be set to 1, just to keep a minimal reading or what do you recommend? Also the natural product locks my pH at around 7.8, which works well with my tub. Will Bromine tablets or Chlorine tablets cause my pH to lower. It's been three months now and my pH has not changed. All other water parameters are perfect. Thanks for your help

Chris, 2/22/2007

Trichlor tablets will dissolve too quickly at the temperature of a spa! I suggest that you use bromine tablets and keep the level
Magnetic water conditioner for pools and spas. at 3-5 PPM. Add a SPA Frog Mineral Sanitizer and you can keep the level at 1-3 PPM. Try running the ozonator for more hours a day. I suggest 4 periods of 2-hours. Make sure that it is working! Chlorine and bromine tablets are acidic and will tend to lower the pH. You can still use the dichlor as a shock. In hot water applications, bromine seems to perform better and is less odorous and irritating. Claiming a product will kill microorganisms requires and EPA registration. Unless your natural product has such a number, it may be wishful thinking. The ozonator will help you use less chlorine or bromine, in order to maintain this lower, but satisfactory level. Otherwise, you seem to doing things correctly and it may be just a matter of getting the bromine additions to better match your spa usage. You are not complaining about scale or hardness problems, so I will assume that The Magnetizer is doing its thing! I hope that this information is helpful.

Sincerely. Alan Schuster, 2/22/2007


Liquid Chlorine And Dichlor?

I am treating a hot tub w/ about 300 gallons. Is there anything fundamentally problematic with liquid sodium hypochlorite 10% solution, aside from the pH, to for in hot tubs. I am interested in using it occasionally to add chlorine AND to raise the pH. I normally use dichlor but it slowly lowers the pH, even when buffered with Na bicarbonate and Na carbonate. I'm currently having trouble keeping the pH up to 7.5 with all the dichlor I use. I sometimes shock with dichlor too as I have a big bather load with kids etc. I'm very careful with testing and I think I can handle the balancing act with these two forms of chlorine, if there is no other issue with sodium hypochlorite.  Thanks.
 
John Brady, 4/27/2010


The reason that liquid chlorine is not recommended is solely because of the high pH and the small volume of water in the typical spa. So long as you are aware of this and are judicious with the amount that you add, I see no reason that you can't use the product, as you have proposed! Testing the water for Free Chlorine and pH before and after each use of the spa, might be a good idea to assure that all of the Free Chlorine has not been depleted by the bathers and that the pH is within range. Using liquid chlorine by itself is not something that I would recommend. For sheer convenience and performance, a salt chlorine generator makes for a better way to do chlorine, as it is controllable and eliminates the odorous forms, as well. No more build-up problems. I hope that I have been helpful. Enjoy the spa.

Sincerely. Alan Schuster, 4/28/2010


Trichlor In A Spa?

I use trichlor tablets in my pool. Can I use them in a spa (completely separate from the pool)?
 
Hank C., 4/17/2010


Trichlor is not used in spas. It may be slow-dissolving in a pool, but the hot water of a spa will dissolve them much quicker.   If you put the tablets in the skimmer, you will risk damage to the heater. Trichlor is very acidic and is not well suited for spa use.  Bromine tablets, in a floating feeder, can provide the type of spa performance, that you associate with trichlor in the pool application. I hope that I have been helpful. 

Sincerely. Alan Schuster, 4/17/2010


Chlorine Tablets And Shock?

What should I use for shock for an inground spa that is maintained with chlorine tablets?

Doug, 3/20/2007

Trichlor tablets are not usually recommended for spa use. The high temperatures make them dissolve too quickly. They should never be added to the skimmer, as corrosion of the heater could result. As a shock, dichlor works well. Potassium monopersulfate is another popular choice. Bromine tablets are better suited for spa use. I would add a SPA FROG mineral sanitizer to reduce the bromine usage and chemical presence. Adding an Ozone Generator will cut the chlorine and shock usage dramatically and produce better water quality. A salt chlorine generator is another way to add chlorine and it a better performing chlorine option.  I hope that I have been helpful.

Sincerely. Alan Schuster, 3/21/2007


Using An Inline Chlorine Feeder?

We have a hot tub with a 2 speed motor. We find it difficult to use the chlorinator because of a too high chlorine reading. The chlorinator is an in-line type. When the 'jets' are turned on, the motor speed doubles, therefore doubling the amount of chlorinated water through the lines. We are currently just putting pucks in the skimmer basket and draining water then adding fresh water to dilute the too high reading. Any suggestions?
 
David M., Niagara Falls, Ontario, 1/14/2007


This type of chlorine will dissolve too quickly at hot tub temperatures. It should not be used, in a residential hot tub or spa, for exactly the problems that you are encountering.  This type of feeder is really meant for a pool.  I suggest that you consider using a SPA FROG Mineral Sanitizer and maintain a free chlorine level at 1-3 PPM or bromine level of 3-5 PPM. Adding an ozonator will make it even easier and allow you to use less chlorine or bromine. If you want to stay with chlorine, a salt chlorine generator would be the better method.  I hope that this information will prove helpful.

Sincerely. Alan Schuster, 1/15/2007


Why Use Stabilized Chlorine?

I am relatively new to the industry and I have a question that doesn't seem to make sense to me. Here goes! Why is stabilized chlorine seem to be the standard sanitizer for spas (when the customer wants to use chlorine). It seems to me that the amount of time a spa (residential) is exposed to the sun is minimal so it would make sense to me to not be adding all that cyanuric acid into the spa. Could you help me with this one. Thanks.

Michael G, 11/25/2004


A good question. It actually has nothing to do with the fact that it is stabilized. Sodium dichlor is completely soluble and close to neutral. Other granular materials, such as calcium hypochlorite and lithium hypochlorite, have a very high pH and that would require constant adjustment in a spa. In addition, calcium hypochlorite is not completely soluble. So if you want a completely soluble and pH neutral granule, dichlor is it!  Welcome to the industry.

Sincerely. Alan Schuster, 11/26/2004


Mixing Chlorine And Bromine?

Alan, I was told not to ever mix Chlorine tablets and Bromine tablets in the spa, what are the possible reactions, if done so in a spa?  You said there is a little Chlorine added to the Bromine tablets already.

Rob, Hawaii, 4/14/2010


Yes, it is true that the bromine tablet do contain a chlorine product. However, when used as directed all of the chlorine will be converted to bromine. Chlorine tablets contain a different chlorine compound and are not recommended for spa use. These tablets are slow dissolving in a pool, but at the temperatures of a spa will dissolve too quickly. This quick dissolution could result in a adverse reaction with the bromine tablets and, in the interest of safety, it is never recommended that different chlorine and bromine products be mixed together in a feeder or other device. I hope that I have been of assistance. Enjoy the spa.

Sincerely. Alan Schuster, 4/14/2010


Chlorine Converting To Bromine?

I’ve read a lot of the material on your site and there’s one thing that keeps cropping up that I just don’t understand. You state that if there are bromine salts in the water when chlorine is added, that the chlorine will be “converted” to bromine. Could you explain this in detail? What is the process by which the chlorine is converted? Thanks in advance.

Gina A., 1/10/2007


When bromide ions are present and chlorine (hypochlorous acid) is added, the bromide ions convert to bromine (hypobromous acid) and the chlorine converts to chloride ions. This is a simple oxidation-reduction chemical reaction and not the literal physical conversion of chlorine to bromine, which would be a fusion reaction.  I hope this explanation will suffice.

Sincerely. Alan Schuster, 1/10/2007


Using Liquid Chlorine?

We use liquid chlorine and acid in our inground pool. We have had no problems with the pool water and are able to maintain the water chemistry. Why can't we use the same chemicals in our spa? Thanks.

Kathy G., Wellington, FL, 5/22/2009


While you did not provide the size of either the pool or spa, I am going to guess that the size of the pool is 12,000 gallons and the spa is 275 gallons. This makes the pool 44 times larger, in terms of the water volume. This does not mean that you will only have to add 1/44th as much chlorine and acid. The higher temperature of spa water increases the amount of wastes being introduced into the water and this will require much more chlorine than that indicated, by a comparison of water volumes. Liquid chlorine has a very high pH and the acid a very low pH. It will be a difficult balancing act, trying to keep the pH in range. Keeping the chlorine level in range, can be even more difficult and you'll find that frequently there will be too much chlorine for bather comfort. It just makes more sense to use an appropriate sanitizer product, in a residential spa. The only chlorine recommended for use in a spa is sodium dichlor because this product is essentially neutral and, therefore, has little effect on the pH. There are other convenient means of spa sanitizing with chlorine, such as a salt chlorine generator. I hope that I have been helpful.

Sincerely. Alan Schuster, 5/22/2009

Return To Top Of Page
 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Thank you for visiting AskAlanAQuestion.Com
If you found the website helpful, please tell your friends and dealers.
If not, please tell us. Your suggestions are appreciated.

 

Aqualab Systems., Inc. does not make any warranty or representation, either expressed or implied, regarding the accuracy or completeness of the information provided by this website; nor does Aqualab Systems., Inc. assume any liability of any kind whatsoever related to, or resulting from, any use or reliance on this information. The content of this website should not be used, if it is conflict with any applicable federal, state or local regulations or guidelines.

©, 2002-14, A.S., Inc. All rights reserved.