askalanaquestion.com . . . a free resource for pool & spa help & information!!!

 

    wpe58.jpg (8414 bytes)     ColorQ Pool 4 hand-held, digital, water analyzer.  

 
  Home
Page
 

Pool
Topics

 

Spa
Topics

 

Website
Shopping

 

Test
Equipment

 

Pool - Spa
Helpline

 
 
 
 

"Metals, Mineral & Stain Problems"
Spa Problems with Discoloration and Staining.
 

The Pool & Spa Informational Website
askalanaquestion.com

Dealing with Staining & Discoloration Issues.

Scroll down to browse through some archived SPA & HOT TUB questions and answers.  Please access the Spa Topics Page and other links, at the top of every page, for additional information.

Mineral content in spa or hot tub water can lead to a variety of problems:  staining of the underwater surfaces, discoloration of the water and corrosion.  Control of trace minerals and maintaining a proper overall spa or hit tub water chemistry is important, to help assure optimum water quality.  Minerals such as iron, manganese and copper are the principal offenders.  Iron and manganese can occur naturally in water, especially well water.  It is the oxidation of dissolved heavy metals that can cause the spa staining and water discoloration problems, upon the addition of oxidizing spa chemicals.  Copper is rarely found in municipal water supplies and usually finds its way into spas and hot tubs as the result of corrosion of the copper heater core or copper plumbing.  Treatment of the resultant problem is usually possible with the proper techniques and chemicals.  Heavy metal staining and discoloration can be removed, treated and prevented, with the use of METALTRAP Products, such as Liquid METALTRAP, METALTRAP Filters, PURESTART Pre-Filter and POOL REFRESH.  Clicking on the underlined and highlighted "keywords" or "catch phrases," in the archived answers will give you access to additional information on that topic or product.  Please refer to the Glossary, if there are terms or phrases that require explanation.

Click any image for more product or ordering information.

More Product and Ordering information about The METALTRAP Filter, The PURESTART Pre-Filter and The METALTRAP Stain Removal System is available, by clicking on the center image, above.  Use these unique products to treat potentially poor quality water and to remove and prevent stains and discoloration, due to iron, copper, manganese, organic contamination & more!  Additional information about some new & unique products, for spas & hot tubs, can be found by visiting The Website Stores You'll never know what you'll find and that's always fun.  Be better prepared and avoid costly problems!

Use Of Softened Water In A Spa?

I just purchased a spa and, following the directions, filled it after bypassing my water softener. My well water contains a fairly high degree of iron and manganese. The result was a spa full of "rust" that the filter was able to remove. However, a rust ring builds up daily on the water line. I spoke with the dealer, he advised that I can fill the spa with soft water. So I drained and refilled the spa with soft water. The ring has been eliminated and, except for a slightly cloudy appearance, the spa is great. Why does the manufacturer recommend NOT using soft water? I want to make sure that I'm not doing any long term damage.
Thanks for your advice.

Dave V., Rehoboth, MA, 2/16/2004

If your household water is of such poor quality as to require a water softener, it should not be used in your spa. The reason being that certain dissolved minerals might be present and might cause discoloration and staining problems.  While it may be possible to treat the dissolved minerals with a quality Mineral Treatment Product, I firmly believe that it is easier and less expensive to use softened water - if you have that option!  Your experience confirms this!  You can easily add chemicals to adjust the pH, hardness and total alkalinity of the softened water and, by doing so, avoid any possible corrosion problems.  The balancing of the pH, hardness and total alkalinity, of the softened water, should completely eliminate any objections by the spa manufacturer. The dealer gave you the right advice!  Why don't spa manufacturers include such advice?  You would have to ask them, but I suspect that because so few people, nationwide, use softened water, they chose not to complicate spa ownership by necessitating softened water in certain areas.   It's just not always required.  There is an alternative that is widely used to solve this type of problem, where there is no water softener or pond or river water us used to fill the spa.  The METALTRAP Filter will permanently remove the heavy metals that might otherwise cause staining and discoloration.  The PURESTART Pre-Filter can remove organic products, that could cause odor and staining.  I hope that I have been helpful.

Sincerely.  Alan Schuster, 2/16/2004



  Using The Right Pre-Filter?

I bought a Micron Prefilter from Micropure (carbon).  The vendor told me it was good for about 3 refill of my spa (450 gallons). I used it once and it doesn't work anymore (water don't go through anymore), but my water has never been so clear!  I think I have a lot of copper in my water because it was always green when I filled it before using that pre-filter.  I'm thinking buying the "Pure Start 1-Micron Pre-Filter, for Spas & Small Pools". Do you think it will be usable for a couple of refills? I know it says 10 000 gallons, but I want your opinion on it.

Isabelle E., Canada, 10/27/2009

The PURESTART 1-Micron Pre-Filter will remove ultra-fine particles and many microorganisms.  It is particularly useful where the source water is of poor quality.  It should be able to be used to refill your spa up to 20 times, depending of the nature of the source water.  However, your description of the water color and the mentioning of a copper possibility, leads me to question, whether a METALTRAP Filter would not be a better choice.  The PURESTART 1-Micron Pre-Filter will remove the metals that have precipitated, but not those in solution.  The "green" color could be copper or iron or both.  The METALTRAP Filter will all the metals, precipitated or dissolved, and will save you from having to deal with discolored water and stained surfaces.  The METALTRAP MT-10 should be able to be used up to 20 times to refill the spa.  You can always test the water, before and after, to confirm the Filter is still effective.  The best way to deal with metals is to physically remove them from the water and not with chemical treatment.  I hope that this information will problem helpful.

Sincerely.  Alan Schuster, 10/27/2009

 

Use Of Well Water In A Spa?

We have a vacation home and plan on adding a spa.  We use well water, which does contain some iron.  For many household uses, we used bottled water.  I have been told that this can cause problems.  What would use suggest?

Phyllis T., Boone, NC, 9/10/2009

Iron can be treated and it a real advantage that you are able top plan ahead.  The METALTRAP Filter will remove iron and other heavy metals, as you fill the spa.  It simples attaches to a garden hose and can treat up to 10,000 gallons of water.  That means you will be able to treat all water added to top off the level and refill the spa, many time over.  If not treated, the iron will cause staining and/or make the water good unappealing.  This cartridge-like device traps the iron inside and that is as good as it gets.  A much better way than any chemical treatments.   hope that this information will prove helpful and that it helps make the Hot Water Experience more enjoyable.

Sincerely.  Alan Schuster,  9/10/2009

Safe & Secure
Shopping
The Magnetizer
Helps Solve Problems?
Find Unique Products in The Website Store.

► Hard Water, Iron & Softened Water?

I live in an area with hard water and iron.  The iron is so bad that it stains everything but it is effectively removed by the water softener.  I have been advised not to used softened water in my spa due to the difficulties in balancing.  I drain the spa for the summer but am considering refilling it from the pool as the sand filter effectively removes the iron color.  I use chlorine in the pool and bromine with ozone in the spa.  Do you see a problem here?  Thanks, great web site.

Frank,  Nova Scotia, Canada, 9/10/2005

The dealer is thoroughly wrong!  It is not difficult to balance the spa water, if you use a water softener.  It is certainly not easier to deal with the iron and hardness!  By all means use the water softener and add a calcium hardness booster to raise the level to about 200 PPM.  Softeners do not always remove metals.  The METALTRAP filter can be used, with a small submersible pump and a garden hose to recirculate the water, through this cartridge-life filter.  It will permanently remove the heavy metals, as the water passes through.  Adjust the pH and total alkalinity, as necessary, and you're good to go.  Using the pool water is a reasonable alternative.  I hope that I have been helpful.

Sincerely.  Alan Schuster, 9/10/2005

 

Is It Black Algae?

I have read all the problems submitted by others. Our discoloration is mostly dark green with many, mottled black spots. The green looks like oxidized copper.  Is it still considered "black algae"?  If so, what do you recommend?

Alan S., 6/16/2004

It is extremely unlikely that the problem is black algae!  It could very well be a copper stain that resulted from corrosion of the copper heater core.  Ask your self the following questions?  Is chlorine or bromine being used?  Has the pH been below 7.0, for extended periods of time?  Are you placing chlorine or bromine in the skimmer?  I suggest that you have the water tested for copper.  If present, that will conform the corrosion.  You will have to drain and clean the spa.  An oxalic or ascorbic acid solution can help remove the stains.  DO NOT USE OXALIC ACID OR ASCORBIC ACID BY MIXING WITH CHLORINE OR BROMINE.  If corrosion was the cause, you need to pay more attention to the pH and total alkalinity of the spa water.  I hope that I have been of assistance.

Sincerely.  Alan Schuster, 6/10/2004

Safe & Secure
Shopping
Need to test
for Heavy Metals?

Visit The Test Equipment Store, for all your needs.

Discolored Water?

I have a 275 gallon spa and recently I emptied, cleaned and refilled the spa.  I added the chemicals (bromine) in the usual way and the spa water started to turn brown in color.  I brought a sample into a local dealer and he said that it was iron.  It never happened before.  Can you explain this?

M. L., 12/17/2004

Where did the iron come from?  That's the real question.  If iron is not normally present in your household water on a regular basis, it might have ended up in your spa water because a fire hydrant was opened somewhere, up line, in the neighborhood.  That caused sediments to be lifted off the bottom of the pipes and the rest you know. It is also possible that your water does contain an occasional trace of iron, depending upon the conditions at the water source, rainfall amounts, etc.  Knowing the amount of iron present is helpful.  Make sure that you add a quality metal treatment, in sufficient quantity, for the amount of iron present.  Add another dose monthly and prior to the addition of makeup water.   The hope that this information cleared things up for you.

Sincerely.  Alan Schuster, 12/7/2004

 

► Only The Spa Is Stained?

I recently purchased an iron test kit from your site, so I'd appreciate a bit more help. Enclosed is a picture of spa water which occurred when the spa person washed the spa filter in muriatic acid and then thoroughly rinsed it.  There have been red rust stains on the spa.  Cistern water tests "no iron" but water you see in the spa tests 0.3 iron.  The spa uses bromine. The pool which uses salt chlorination and shows no rust stains. I've just replaced the spa gas heat exchanger (now cupronickel) and there's no other source of rust. The whole house water filter DOES, however, fill with a reddish material on the 1 micron filter we use to filter it out. We believe that the dirt on the hillside in the Virgin Islands (red) has a lot of iron in it.  Please answer this:  Why does the spa show iron stains and not the pool?  Does the bromine precipitate any iron that is in the water?  Does salt generated chlorine not precipitate iron so the pool does NOT get stains?  Do you think we need a specific iron filter?  Thanks.

 
Norm, Virgin Islands, 4/30/2007

Red colored soil usually is high in iron.  There is a possibility that copper is interring with the iron test and is showing up as iron.  What I see in the spa are not iron stains.  Copper stains from corrosion of the heater core are more likely.  The action of chlorine or bromine, upon iron or copper is virtually the same.  Iron stains are yellow to rust colored.  Copper stains are blue-green to black.  You replaced the heater coil, why?  The pool operates with a salt chlorine generator.  Low pH is rare, because the SCG drives up the pH.  Bromine or chlorine will not attack copper unless the pH is acidic.  Most likely the pool's pH is always around 7.8 or higher.  The spa is using bromine and bromine tablets are acidic.  If the pH drops below 7.0, corrosion and staining could result.  The photo seems to show that.  If you used bromine tablets and did not add pH Increaser on a regular basis, your pH was too low.  I think you need to do the following.  Add several doses of a metal treatment to the pool and spa.  Add another monthly.  Use a metal removing prefilter, while adding any new water to the pool or spa, to help remove particulated iron.  For cleaning of the spa stains try using a solution of ascorbic acid (vitamin C)  Refer to the pool page on staining problems for more on this topic.  I hope that this information is helpful.

 
Sincerely.  Alan Schuster, 4/30/2007

 

► Well Water Containing Sulfur?

I observed floating particles in our hot tub. The flakes are yellow in color, have the texture of dead skin and can be up to half an inch in size in some cases. We use water direct from our well which contains 5 ppm of sulphur. When I asked our local dealer about the problem, he stated that this is due to the sulphur attacking the lining of the rubber hose plumbing. The sulphur eventually lifts off flakes of the hose which take on the color of the sulphur. He said that the remedy for this is to use a stain control product which keeps the sulphur particles suspended (sequestered) in the water thus keeping the sulphur from etching the rubber lining. He said that this can begin to occur after about sixteen months of use which makes sense in our case. I have begun the use of the stain control and will continue to observe for improvements.  Have you ever seen this condition or heard of this remedy?

Dennis, Canada, 1/12/2007

You can't sequester sulfur compounds.  But there is a solution.  The PURESTART Pre-Filter will remove lots of the minerals that cause odors and discoloration.  Use it every time you fill the spa and you'll save yourself a lot of problems.

If this is the only source of water, I would bring in a sample of fresh water and have it tested for pH, TA and calcium hardness.  I would allow the chlorine level to reach zero, add a 1/4 pound of ascorbic acid (METALTRAP Stain Remover) and let the water recirculate for at least 12 hours.  Drain and clean the spa.  Use a metal removing PreFiller to treat the new water, as the spa is being refilled.  Always prefilter new water.  Adding a monthly dose of calcium treatment is a good idea, if the hardness level is over 200 PPM.  I hope that this information will prove helpful.

Sincerely.  Alan Schuster, 1/13/2007

 

► Well Water Causing Discoloration?

Awesome site and thanks for the help up front. I have had a spa at my cabin since last September.  The water was cloudy and needed to be changed because it was a couple of months old and had an odor.  I drained the tub completely via the drain port and wiped down the interior.  I refilled the tub with water, which holds about 450 gallons, from my well.  The water was tested when we bought the cabin and has very little iron in it.  However, I do think we have sulfates dissolved in the water because we do have a tinge of sulfur smell.  I have suspended solids in the water and need to get a micro-filter to capture the solids that settle out on the bottom of the tub, but that is another story.  I added 16 oz of metal treatment.  I added shock treatment, installed a new bromine cartridge and some type of water polisher that is supposed to help clear the water.  Note suspended solids above.  The tub ran for 20 to 30 minutes and then I tested the water.  The water hardness was low as were the pH and alkalinity.  Added 10 to 12 oz. of calcium based on the calculation that 1 oz will add about 10 ppm to the water.  I also adjusted the pH and alkalinity using a spa-up product.  I got the pH in range, the alkalinity was high but I've learned that pH is the important number.  Bromine seemed good at about 2 ppm.  I have an ozonator and a mineral cartridge in the system, which I did not change.  I put the cover down and came back in a half hour.  Lifted the cover and the water was clear but a yellowish-green color.  I've been reading your site ever since.  I read a question that talked about copper in the water turning someone's hair and nails green.  I didn't jump in to see if the same would happen to me.  Any thoughts?  This didn't happen when the tub was filled the first or second time, but the third time was not the charm.  Thanks.

Dan K.,  St. Paul, MN. 3/20/2007

Spas that turn color after chlorine has been added usually have a metals problem, leading to staining and/or discoloration.  This can be very common with well water.  ASAP add at least a double dose of a quality metal treatment.  This might help avoid staining and should make an improvement.  Bring in a water sample to a local dealer and have the water tested for iron, copper and other parameters.  I suggest adding a dose of metal treatment for each 0.5 PPM of metals.  Add another dose prior to adding new water.  A monthly dose is an additional safeguard against a recurring problem.  A metal and mineral removing prefilter could make a big difference, when used to treat all new water.  Only a Spa Frog mineral sanitizer can be used with bromine.  In addition, it is unlikely to be affected by the metal treatment.  In the future, you should consider using a METALTRAP Filter to remove the metals, as the sap is being filled.  A single METAL TRAP will last loner enough to fill the spa, more than a dozen times.  I hope that I have been helpful.

Sincerely.  Alan Schuster. 3/20/2007

 

Turned Brown?

We were changing the water and we added the calcium hardness treatment. Then we add the bromine and it turns brown. We have changed the water regularly and this has never happened before.  What is wrong?

Linda M., 4/15/2007

This sounds like a spa, but you didn't make that clear.  Either way, everything applies.  Pools/spas that turn color after bromine has been added usually have a metals problem.  This can be very common with well water.  ASAP add at least a double dose of a quality metal treatment.  This might help avoid staining and should make an improvement.  Bring in a water sample to a local dealer and have the water tested for iron, copper and other parameters.  I suggest adding a dose of metal treatment for each 0.5 PPM of metals.  Add another dose prior to adding new water.  A monthly dose is an additional safeguard against a recurring problem.  To help avoid such problems, I suggest using a metal removing prefilter  It can remove much of the metal content and help avoid such problems.  I hope that this information proves helpful.

Sincerely.  Alan Schuster, 4/17/2007

 

Tannins In Well Water?

I have well water and it contains tannin.  Do you know how I can filter it out of the water?  Thank you.

Amy R., 3/28/2007

Tannins will turn the water a tea color.  You should be able to destroy them, merely by adding some extra chlorine.  Raise the level to 5 PPM.  Well water can contain metals and you should treat the water, by adding a metal treatment.  To be on the safe side, you might consider using a PURESTART prefilter, as it can help filter out particulates and metals found in well water.  Use it to treat all new water added to the spa.  It will last through many fill ups and the chemicals saving will make it pay for itself.  Doing this will save you a lot of headaches, should metals be present.  I hope this information is helpful.

Sincerely.  Alan Schuster, 3/29/2007

 

► Black Spots?

My spa and pool are 4 years old.  I have been treating my spa for what I thought was Black Algae for the last five weeks.  The temperature finally cooled off so I could empty it and scrape off a sample.  I took the sample to the pool supply place and they determined it was metallic.  There are two spots, about the size of silver dollars, on the side of the spa.  What could be causing this?  Thank you.

Jake G., 10/29/2003

The stains could be the result of copper, in the presence of high levels of calcium hardness.  The copper could have come from corrosion of the heater.  Assuming that the spa and pool are gunite, try putting about 1/2 pound of pH reducer in a sock and place on a spot.  Leave in place for about 30 minutes.  Hopefully, this will dissolve the upper layer of plaster and remove the stain.  Sometimes, it is necessary to use ascorbic acid (METALTRAP Stain Remover) for this purpose.  Sometimes black spots form, as a result of the use and abuse of calcium chloride in the plaster mixture.  This problem was well described in the 1/15/03 issue of Service Industry News (Carlsbad, CA).  If this is the case, there is nothing that is known to eliminate the problem, short of refinishing.  I hope that the information will prove helpful.

Sincerely.  Alan Schuster, 10/29/2003

 

► Green Gunk?

We have a fiberglass spa (500 gal) and it has developed green "gunk" (for lack of a better description).  This stuff is in small chunks and adheres to the sides of the tub, our suits, of course it's filling the filter and it's covering the plastic parts of the filter.  If it lands on anything while hosing out the filter, it sticks like glue.   It can be scrapped off the tub and filter.  What caused it and how do we get rid of it?   We switched from bromine to chlorine, could that have caused it?   We drained and cleaned the tub and filter before switching.  Thanks.

Kay & Jim, Florida, 3/10/2005

This "green gunk" could be copper, resulting from corrosion of the filter.  Not a good thing!  Have you been failing to maintain the pH at 7.2-7.8?  Low pH conditions will corrode the copper heater core, in the presence of chlorine or bromine.  Chlorine tablets should not ever be used in a spa, especially not in the skimmer.  I suggest that you have the water tested for copper.  If present, it is the result of corrosion and low pH.  Add a double dose of a quality metal treatment and make sure that the pH is 7.2-7.8, at all times.  You might be better off draining the spa, if my assumptions are correct.  Otherwise, get back to me with the actual water analysis results and the type of chemicals being used.  Have you ever considered an ozonator?  It will make spa maintenance easier and produce better water quality, with fewer chemicals.  I hope that this information will prove helpful.

Sincerely.  Alan Schuster, 3/10/2005

 

Black Deposits?

I am in Lake Tahoe, Nevada.  I operate an indoor swimming pool and spa at an estate.  Neither the pool or the spa gets used much. I am having a problem with the spa.  On several occasions I have found a very black substance that almost appears to be a fungus that is attacking the chrome vents on the sides and bottom of the spa.  The spa is made of imported tiles and the black substance always starts at the chrome and begins traveling into the grout lines. Today, I drained the spa and sprayed household bleach on the spots.  It did nothing and I then sprayed Muriatic acid on the spots and they dissolved.   I just purchased a 9-way test kit so I can get specific readings for pH, hardness etc. I'm not sure where to go from here.  The local pool guy had no idea what this problem could be.  Any help would be greatly appreciated.  Regards.

Tim M., Lake Tahoe, NV 5/11/2004

The problem is positively not a fungus, mold, mildew, algae or bacteria.  Otherwise the liquid chlorine that you sprayed on would have had a positive effect.  The fact the muriatic acid dissolved the black deposits means that the problem is due to a metallic or mineral stain.  There are a few possibilities.  The water used to fill the units may contain trace amounts of iron and other heavy metals.  Testing the spa water as well as the tap water can help conform this possibility.  In any event, because it is a metal or mineral problem, I suggest that you add a dose of a quality metal treatment monthly and prior to the addition of any new makeup water.  The other possibility is that the deposits are being caused by the oxidation of the products of corrosion.  The copper heater core and other metal parts might have been subjected to the corrosive forces of acidic water conditions.  Copper can cause dark stains in the presence of high levels of calcium hardness, although high calcium, by itself, will not cause such a problem.  Make sure that the pH remains in the 7.2-7.6 range and the total alkalinity is not below 80-120 PPM.  Either or both of these possibilities could have been the cause and these steps should help avoid a recurrence.  If you are using trichlor, make sure that the feeder in plumbed after the heater and that there is a check valve between the two.  I hope that this information proves helpful.

Sincerely.  Alan Schuster, 5/12/2004

 

► Bad Advice & Softened Well Water?

I have a 375 gallon spa.  I just emptied and refilled it for the first time.  When I initially filled it I use a Metal Treatment product, as I use well water (softened) to fill the spa.  I also use calcium booster to increase the calcium for the softened water.  I had no problems.  This time I went to a different spa dealer and was told to use a stain and scale control for the metal.  My water turned brown when I added my bromine.  The dealer assures me this is what I need to get rid of the metal.  The directions say 1 oz. per 300/gals.  I have used 9 ounces with no luck.  Should I use more or was this the wrong advice?

Mary, 1/19/2005

Probably the wrong product.  Having used softened water, you don't need to use a scale control product.  In fact, if you used a combination of softened and unsoftened water, you wouldn't need to add any calcium hardness booster.  Water softeners may not remove heavy metals such as iron, copper or manganese.  Proper treatment requires a dose of a quality Metal Treatment for each 0.5 PPM of heavy metals.  Otherwise, upon adding chlorine or bromine and/or raising the pH and total alkalinity, the water may discolor or cause staining.  This is exactly what happened, according to your description.  I suggest that you consider adding Liquid METALTRAP, as soon as possible.  It is a true chelating agent and does not contain phosphonic acid derivatives.  It will not degrade over time and is not affected by high pH, as are most of the typical metal treatments.  Add at least a double dose and expect a day or so for improvement.  In the future, you know the plan!  Enjoy the spa and I hope that the advice proves helpful.

Sincerely.  Alan Schuster, 1/19/2005

 

Blue Stains?

I have some blue-colored stains near some jets and on the bottom.  Could this have been caused by copper?  The spa is about 300 gallons and is about 12 years old.  I use bromine tablets and a non-chlorine shock.  Is there anything that I can do?  Thanks.

Anthony N.,  VT, 10/30/2003

The blue-colored stains are probably due to copper.  The likely source is from your heater.  If you're lucky, the damage to the heater was not serious. You didn't mention that there was any discoloration of the water, so I will assume that there was none.  That being the case, you probably don't have much copper in the water.  A Copper Test should confirm this.  To avoid staining, I suggest that you add a dose of a quality Spa Mineral Treatment to the spa water.  The next time that the spa is emptied, try cleaning the stained areas with the same Spa Mineral Treatment.  Make sure that you use rubber gloves and eye protection.  Rinse any metal parts with water, to remove the chemicals and the dissolved stains.  Rinse spa clean before it is refilled and don't forget to add a dose of the spa Mineral Treatment, as it is being refilled.  The cause of the copper problem was probably due to corrosive, low pH conditions.  In the future, make sure that the pH remains in the 7.2-7.8 range.  To help stabilize the pH, the total alkalinity should be 80-120 PPM.  I hope that I have been helpful.  Keep enjoying the spa.

Sincerely.  Alan Schuster, 10/30/2003

 

► Stain Removal In Pool/Spa Combo?

I have a large in-ground pool/spa, 7 years old, kidney shaped, about 30,000 gallons. It has had a Copper Ionization + ozone system on it for about 5 years. Over the years, the pool service did not maintain the pH properly and the pool has developed gray stains. A drain and acid wash is recommended by my pool service but I am reluctant to proceed due to the expense and the impact it has on the pool surface finish. My pool technician, has suggested that he has been successful in treating stains like these with the addition of Muriatic acid to the water. I am willing to give this process a try as it appears cost effective and should not damage the finish. I would like to try the treatment on the spa first, and see if it is successful. If yes, than I would like to do it to the whole pool. What are the pros and cons to this approach? How much Muriatic acid needs to be added for success? My spa is 8 feet in diameter. How many gallons of acid for the 30,000 gallon pool? How long should I let this circulate? Are there different strengths of Muriatic acid? Which one should I use? What is the best way to restore the water chemistry after this operation? Thanks.

M.B., 10/24/2007

A pool or spa be subjected to an acid bath as a means of stain removal.  Basically it dissolves the top surface and hopefully takes the stain with it.  Lowering the pH will subject the metal parts to corrosion, including the heater, if chlorine or bromine are present.  Therefore, treatment should be in terms of a short period of time - a day or less.  This is important to help minimize the possibility of excessive surface etching.  You have to add enough acid to lower the pH below lower pH readings on the testers.  A pH of about 6.0 should suffice.  Use the brush to scrub the surface.  Bypass the heater, if possible.  A better and safer method is to use the METALTRAP Stain Removal System.  Once the discolorations and stains are removed, use The METALTRAP Filter, for all future water addition and the problem should not recur.  Restore the pH and TA.  Because the addition of the metal treatment will interfere with the copper being introduced by the ionization unit, I would recommend using a polymer algaecide for a month or two, while the copper ion content is re-established.  I hope that this information proves helpful.

Sincerely.  Alan Schuster, 10/24/2007

Proper water chemistry will help to better control and avoid sanitation problems and maintain more optimum bathing conditions.  More information about Pool/Spa Water Testing Products can be found in the Test Equipment Store.

 

 (Click on any image for ordering and information.)

  Return To Top Of Page  

Thank you for visiting AskAlanAQuestion.Com.  If you found the website helpful, please tell your friends and dealers.  If not, please tell us.  Your suggestions are appreciated.

 

Aqualab Systems., Inc. does not make any warranty or representation, either expressed or implied, regarding the accuracy or completeness of the information provided by this website; nor does Aqualab Systems., Inc. assume any liability of any kind whatsoever related to, or resulting from, any use or reliance on this information.  The content of this website should not be used, if it is conflict with any applicable federal, state or local regulations or guidelines.

©,  2002-10, A.S., Inc.  All rights reserved.
 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 Hit Counter